Tips for Bagging Eastern Coyotes

You'd never be expected to kill 50 coyotes in a year, but we found two hunters who expect it. Here are four tactics they use to get it done.

Tips for Bagging Eastern Coyotes

Paying attention to details — from noting wind direction to masking your presence walking to stand and standing during calling sessions — is the first step to bagging 50 coyotes a year. (Credit: iStock)

Many hunters make goals for themselves at the beginning of each predator calling season. This is a terrific idea because setting goals provides focus for achieving a task. Newbie hunters may give themselves a winter to kill their first coyote. Cagey veteran eastern callers may strive for a dozen song dogs. I know of a pair of hunters who annually strive for 50 coyotes! That’s right ... 50 coyotes!

Jon Robla, 31, and Ben McAllister, 28, hail from Norwood, New York. The two hunters met four years ago through mutual friends. As the only predator hunters in their circle of friends, it was inevitable they would join up for some hunts. Robla and McAllister quickly discovered they had huge amounts of land access and should manage their hunting spots for maximum productivity.

Their method of hunting is strictly calling. No bait, no running with dogs. Their total is achieved through run-and-gun calling efforts! Here are tips for how they do it.

Tips for Eastern Coyotes

Pass On Foxes

As I experienced while hunting with Robla, the pair of hunters do not shoot at foxes that willingly charge into their call during the first three minutes of calling. Instead, they let these frisky foxes go and wait for coyotes to appear.

“It’s amazing to see how many coyotes come in minutes later, after a fox appears. Many hunters do not realize this because they shoot the fox, collect it and move on,” Robla said. Make no mistake, the pair do shoot foxes, but they shoot them later in the set or not at all when hunting in areas with a high likelihood of a coyote appearing.

Rely On Silence

Again, I experienced this calling tactic firsthand. Robla truly relied on silence during each setup. We sat in silence for up to 50 percent of the total stand time. Robla indicated that coyotes appear 50 percent of the time when waiting in silence. He related his tactic to giving a toddler a lollypop. When the child has the lollypop in hand, he is content and gives it attention. When the lollypop is taken away, he really wants it and does what it takes to get it back. According to Robla, the same goes with responding coyotes and calling sounds.

Regulate Your Stand Length

Don’t adhere to a predetermined stand length (aka the 15-minute rule). Develop your stands based upon your findings in the field. Robla stays 25 minutes at each coyote stand. This isn’t simply an arbitrary number he selected. He was noticing that if he broke a stand earlier, he was seeing or hearing coyotes in the area where was previously calling from. As a result, he lengthened his stand time and his fur count went up.

Master Your Lights

Let’s face it: thermal night-vision packages are expensive. The bottom line is that many hunters simply cannot afford a high-end scanning and shooting thermal system. That is why Robla encourages all hunters to learn how to effectively use the myriad LED light systems on the market today.

How They Do It

What does it take to kill 50 eastern coyotes in a single season? Robla shared his insight on calling these formidable creatures that he, admittedly, has a great deal of respect and admiration for.

The first thing for success was Robla and McAllister had to combine their hunting styles. They had their own tendencies and had to come to consensus while together on stand. When thinking about the factors of calling (volume, frequency and duration), Robla considers himself a conservative caller, while McAllister is more aggressive. According to Robla, they still are working on blending their individual styles, but always find a groove when it comes time to putting fur in the truck. Good thing, too, because the pair enter as many regional calling contests as they can find.

While looking for potential calling spots, they agree that a prime location should be next to “holding areas” where coyotes can forage and rest in the day. The terrain is best if it offers a high vantage point from which to call and downwind view of predator approach routes.

Although 95 percent of their success comes while hunting at night, they also enjoy daytime calling. Work commitments and family responsibilities make night hunting more plausible and the pair have honed their skills for mastering the night shift. Their favorite night hunting spots are huge, open fields where they can see coyotes approaching from great distances.

One would tend to believe that Robla and McAllister must hunt every conceivable night to amass such high totals. Surprisingly, they don’t. Robla likes to get out at least once a week, but sometimes more. The factor is weather. He doesn’t hunt during inclement weather and his area has plenty of that. They also do not like to overhunt their areas. Exactly how often they hunt an area depends upon prior results.

If they kill a female coyote, they will return the next night and try to lure the single male. If they “educate” a coyote with a missed shot or other mishap, they will not return for a month. On that return, they completely change their hunting tactics: new setup location, new sounds, new time of hunt. They do everything in their power to change the scenario. On average, the pair make three stands per night, unless they are in a contest; then the number swells to 15.

Calling Sequences

The hunters employ a specific calling sequence for the majority of their stands. To start the session, they use a prey distress sound for 3-5 minutes. They rotate the prey sounds and do not rely on any one particular sound to start every set. This is done to keep things fresh for the resident coyotes.

If nothing appears, after waiting several minutes in silence, to the initial sounds they will add coyote vocalizations. Robla likes to use primarily female vocalizations and generally refrains from using alpha male sounds. Again, they use a variety of coyote howls as played through either their Foxpro Fusion call or through mouth calls. He lists his favorites as Female Submissive and Female Lone Howls. Coyote-pup-distress sounds are played after the howls. If still nothing shows, another series of prey distress sounds is played, followed by more coyote vocalizations. After a lengthy calling session, the stand is broken down. They use this calling format throughout the calling season, but find it especially productive in the later portions of the season when coyotes are mating or searching for mates.

Thermal Optics

Robla and McAllister rely on thermal optics for their exploits. McAllister was first to take the plunge. His wanted to film his hunts and realized that thermal units could allow him to do so. Robla, who achieved crazy coyote calling success in the 2015-16 season while using a conventional red LED scanning and gun-mounted red LED shooting light combination, stepped into the world of thermal hunting for the 2016-17 calling season. He uses a IR Defense MARK-2 shooting scope and IR Defense Patrol helmet mounted unit for scanning.

But thermal doesn’t make coyotes come crashing into every setup. Hunters still need to pay strict attention to proven and effective approach, setup and calling tactics.

“Thermal doesn’t make them come to the call,” Robla said. He does credit thermal for eliminating issues that can cause coyotes to spook with other scanning lights. Issues such as LED lights being too bright, transition blunders from scanning to shooting lights, or worrying about light splash are a thing of the past in the thermal world.

McAllister adds that it is “educational and fascinating to watch coyotes come to the call with their natural reaction instead of being influenced by the glow of red light that is often cast upon them.”

He also mentions that he can detect incoming coyotes at great distances and that allows him ample time to prepare for the shot. According to Robla, using thermal over the course of a long night can get tiresome on the eyes and that judging distance can be difficult, so it really helps to know the landscape well.


Comments on this site are submitted by users and are not endorsed by nor do they reflect the views or opinions of COLE Publishing, Inc. Comments are moderated before being posted.